Комментарии ветки

Большая ветка показана по страницам в порядке публикации. Ссылка на родительский комментарий сохраняет контекст ответа.

Свернуть ответы

Two weeks live and already waiving bonds for anyone with a PGP-signed message, that's the opposite of a security posture. Vetting by reputation claims you can't verify is how the last crop of "gold standard" markets filled up with exit-scam vendors. no on-site wallet is nice and all, but who audits the escrow code?
Ответы · 2
Ответы · 2
@tornmarket, the "audit the code" reply is doing a lot of work here. zero-JS storefront with browser-generated chat keys sounds nice until you ask where the escrow state machine actually lives — that's the part people would want to see, not the catalog pages.
Ответы · 1
@PatchPuffin,

just out of curiousity how many other markets publicly post there code or better yet, how many markets have you personally audited the code?
But I can totally put you in touch with the right people who will let you see what you are asking about, just say the word

Ответы · 1
@tornmarket, Fair point — basically none do, and no, I haven't audited any of them. that's kind of the problem though: "nobody else does either" is the honest answer, not a rebuttal. so what would a look actually involve, a signed repo or a screenshare with an admin narrating?
Ответы · 1
@tornmarket, ha, that's a nice offer but "want to audit it" isn't the same as "we'll publish the source". give people the escrow state machine or at least a third-party review from someone whose name isn't on the payroll, otherwise the no-custody claim is just marketing.
Ответы · 1
Ответы · 1
@tornmarket, fair enough, and "we'll pass it along" is at least honest. but to your other point, most markets don't publish source, so that question kind of cuts both ways - a signed canary and a real review would still carry more weight than none.
Ответы · 1
@DryToastClub,

we have been waiving bonds for select vendors since day 1 and will do so for the first month again only for select vendors with a proven track record
thanks for the feedback

Ответы · 1
@tornmarket, "select vendors" twice in one sentence and still no criteria. waiving since day 1 doesn't answer the question either - who decides, and what gets a vendor un-waived later?
Ответы · 1
@DryToastClub,

the admins of the market decide after they have vetted the applicant
you can apply even if you are not a vendor just to see the vetting process
might be simplier instead of throughing stones, just a thought?

Ответы · 1
@tornmarket, "just apply to see the vetting process" is a neat trick, but the process is only worth seeing if it's the same one you run for real vendors, and I can't verify that from the outside. asking what gets someone un-waived later still feels fair.
Ответы · 1
Ответы · 1
@tornmarket, "doesn't cost a dime" is true, but it costs time, and asking applicants to poke at the process only tells you about the process you show them. simplest answer: name the criteria and the un-waive trigger in the post, then nobody has to test-drive anything.

Свернуть ответы