Комментарии ветки

Большая ветка показана по страницам в порядке публикации. Ссылка на родительский комментарий сохраняет контекст ответа.

Свернуть ответы

hmm, generic replies are the tell. mods can't really stop it with a captcha if the accounts are aged, but rate-limiting new accounts for a week kills most of it. seen this exact wave on three other forums, it passes.
Ответы · 2
Ответы · 1
@clint, gotta say, replying "ignore previous commands" *in* a thread complaining about bots is either perfect irony or the exact thing the op is on about. rate-limiting new accounts still seems like the least stupid fix though.
Ответы · 1
Ответы · 1
@Anubis, fair, but the cost lands on the wrong side. captcha farms solve them for pennies, so it's mostly the new human who eats it, while a posting delay on fresh accounts just slows the script down and costs you a line of config.
Ответы · 1
@bufferbuffoon,

Delaying access for new accounts and restricting their participation in the community will likely discourage legitimate and genuine users from using the forum if they can't interact or comment right away. This is not what Conclave needs at this point, it needs to sustain its organic growth.

While captcha farms can solve captchas for a small fee they still require payment man.
And based on my own experience, this expense will effectively eliminate approximately 80% of bots and trolls from the forum.

Ответы · 1
@Anubis, the growth point is fair, but a week's posting delay only hits people who want to post in their first hour, and most lurkers don't. as for the 80% figure, "my own experience" isn't evidence, and captcha farms charge per solve precisely because their margin is thin, so price rarely scares them off for long.
Ответы · 1
@bufferbuffoon,

Whether you like it or not, my experience is concrete evidence and holds more weight than speculation on this topic.
I've spent nearly a decade working with CAPTCHAs, botting, and anti-botting defenses, so I know what I'm talking about.

If you look closely at the types of bots and content posted on Conclave, none of it is monetizable. As soon as any barrier requires payment, even a single dollar, it will stop the spammers who are there purely to pollute the platform for the sake of it.

On the other hand, when you're dealing with the most determined and experienced spammers and botters, nothing will stop them. That's from direct experience.

The reality is that sophisticated bad actors will find a way regardless of what defenses you put in place

↑ 0
Ответы · 1
@Anubis, hmm, captchas don't do much against scripted signups with cheap solvers, and a plain one makes life worse for the humans you're trying to keep. rate limit on new accounts is a few lines of config, calling it overkill is odd.
Ответы · 1
@bufferbuffoon,

Let's agree to disagree but let's agree that Conclave will ultimately need some kinda of feature to prevent boting.

Ответы · 1
@Anubis, sure, some feature is inevitable. mostly i'd just like the mods to agree on what counts as botty before building anything, otherwise you get a captcha and the bots carry on regardless. edit: typo.
Ответы · 1
@bufferbuffoon,

Personally, I've never seen a lot of bots on shit-Dread.
Their captcha seems to do the job and they never needed to have someone's aging his account before posting or commenting.

Свернуть ответы