JustMix JustMix[A]II

Liquidity or Privacy?

In the cryptocurrency space, Bitcoin and Monero are discussed most often. Both networks operate on the basis of Proof-of-Work, but they address different objectives. Bitcoin was created as a decentralized electronic cash system, but over time it evolved into the most liquid and scarce digital asset. Monero, from the very beginning, was developed as a means of making private payments in which the amount and the participants of a transaction are not publicly disclosed.

This raises a practical question: which cryptocurrency should be used for payments, and is it necessary to choose only one? The answer depends on your priorities. Bitcoin is easier to buy, sell, and use across different services, while Monero provides stronger protection for financial information directly at the protocol level.

The Origins of Bitcoin

In October 2008, a person using the pseudonym Satoshi Nakamoto published the Bitcoin white paper, Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System. It described an electronic monetary system capable of operating without a central bank or trusted intermediary.

On January 3, 2009, Nakamoto created the first block of the Bitcoin network. It included a headline from the British newspaper The Times about a possible second bailout of the banks. This is often interpreted as a comment on the problems of the traditional financial system. A few days later, the first Bitcoin software client was released, and on January 12, 2009, the first known transaction on the network took place: a transfer from Satoshi Nakamoto to developer Hal Finney.

Bitcoin’s key innovation was solving the double-spending problem without a central operator. All transactions are recorded in a shared public ledger - the blockchain - and its integrity is maintained by miners and the Proof-of-Work mechanism.

Over time, Bitcoin came to be used not only as a means of payment but also as a scarce digital asset. Its maximum supply of 21 million coins and its predetermined issuance schedule made it popular among those who view cryptocurrency as a digital equivalent of gold.
The Origins of Monero

Monero was launched in April 2014. The project grew out of the ideas behind the CryptoNote protocol, which proposed ways to conceal the participants and amounts of cryptocurrency transactions. Initially, the developers used a codebase associated with Bytecoin, and the new project was named BitMonero. It was later renamed Monero.

Unlike Bitcoin, Monero was created from the outset with an emphasis on privacy and the fungibility of its coins. The project had no premine and no separate share of the issuance reserved for its developers. Its supporters believed that a fully public payment history was poorly suited to everyday digital money.

The ideas behind Monero can be described as cash in the cryptocurrency world: no AML checks, no assessment of a coin’s origin, and no analysis of its transaction history.

Bitcoin is often described as a pseudonymous system. An address does not contain the owner’s name; however, transactions, amounts, and the movement of funds on its blockchain are open to everyone. If an address is linked to a person through an exchange, a store, a public announcement, or other information, the transactions associated with it can be tracked and analyzed.

Monero conceals the key details of a payment directly at the protocol level. Ring signatures hide the actual sender among several possible participants, one-time stealth addresses create a separate address for every transaction, and RingCT technology hides the amount being transferred.

As a result, a standard Monero transaction does not directly reveal to an observer who sent the coins, who received them, or exactly how much was transferred. Privacy is enabled by default, so users do not need to select a special mode or configure each transaction individually.

So Why Is Bitcoin More Convenient?

Despite all of Monero’s advantages, these same advantages have been strongly disliked by regulators. At present, only a handful of exchanges can be found where Monero is openly traded. Currently, surprising as it may sound, Iran has been relatively successful in trading Monero. This is more likely connected to the country’s extensive restrictions and sanctions than to any government support for anonymity.

However, because Monero transactions cannot be tracked, the cryptocurrency is excluded from trading in many other jurisdictions, which significantly harms its liquidity.

At the same time, Bitcoin’s main advantage is liquidity. It is supported by most major exchanges, wallets, payment services, and cryptocurrency applications. Bitcoin is easier to purchase with fiat currency, transfer to another platform, exchange for other assets, or sell again. That is why it remains the universal “base currency” of the crypto market.

Bitcoin is also more widely used outside exchanges. It is supported by payment providers, stores, investment services, and companies working with digital assets. This does not mean that every merchant accepts BTC directly, but purchasing goods and services with Bitcoin is generally easier: it can either be used directly or quickly exchanged for the required currency. With Monero, the range of such opportunities is considerably smaller.

How Private Can Bitcoin Be?

Despite all its advantages, one important point must be made about Bitcoin: its blockchain remains public, and transactions can still be traced. Bitcoin is not a completely anonymous currency. However, tools exist that can make it more difficult to link a transaction to a specific person. These include mixers, CoinJoin, PayJoin, and certain second-layer solutions.

The result depends on the specific service, the user’s behavior, subsequent transactions, and network data. Nevertheless, it is possible to improve Bitcoin’s privacy while retaining its main advantage - liquidity.

So Which One Is Better?

In reality, it is important to understand that Monero and Bitcoin are not irreconcilable enemies. They are two types of cryptocurrency that, above all, challenge the monopoly over money held by governments, corporations, and banks.

Their ideological foundation is similar, but their areas of application differ. Monero is more focused on privacy-oriented and underground markets, and it is actively used by people who are willing to sacrifice convenience for a higher level of built-in privacy. Bitcoin, meanwhile, exists across a huge number of platforms alongside Monero, but it is also the primary route for moving funds from the darknet into the ordinary world.

Therefore, maintaining privacy while retaining liquid assets does not require completely abandoning one cryptocurrency in favor of the other. Instead, it makes more sense to combine their strengths while offsetting their weaknesses.

↑ 2

Обсуждение

Комментарии

1

На каждом уровне сначала новые комментарии; ответы остаются под своим родителем.

Написать Join — чтобы участвовать в обсуждении.

The part people usually skip: monero's liquidity problem is survivable if you plan around it. Keep your spendable funds in xmr, but do the swap to btc only when you actually need to move value into the regular world, not in a panic after you need it.