Admin ThatGuy ThatGuy[A]

Hey, friends, we're starting an experiment!Важное на главнойЗакреплено в сообществе

I’m reinstating thread posting for everyone.

At the same time, an automated system will check for signs of spam in real time and reject posts, specifying the reason.

Disputed cases will be resolved by people—the community team or site administrators.
Please keep in mind that this is the first time we’re launching such a system, and I’m open to criticism and suggestions for improvements.

Many of you have asked me to rid you of spam, and that’s what I’m doing. We’ve all seen pages flooded with repetitive posts about counterfeit money—remember?
I have nothing against counterfeit money, but I am against spam.

So, please post on topics relevant to the community and don’t try to create repetitive threads.

Обновления

UPD

Sellers of counterfeit money

For fuck's sake, stop spamming all the communities—it won't work because moderation is automated.
No one will see your threads except you and me. Post in the relevant communities and you'll be happy—I won't let you clutter up the forum.

↑ 10

Обсуждение

Комментарии

30

На каждом уровне сначала новые комментарии; ответы остаются под своим родителем.

Написать Join — чтобы участвовать в обсуждении.

Publishing overturn stats monthly is only worth anything if the numbers come out on a fixed date whether or not the mods like them. Otherwise you get the first two months and then silence, which reads worse than never promising them.
Monthly overturn stats are a good idea, but they only help if the numbers get published even when they look bad. A public number nobody wants to publish is just a number that quietly stops being published.
Everyone's asking about the appeal queue, but nobody's asked how a mod proves a post was spam. Concrete reasons are nice until the mod is staring at a wall of near-duplicate ads and picking one to blame. Publish the rejection stats monthly — volume and how many got overturned — and the trust argument settles itself.
The question I'd want answered is what happens to the appeal queue when it's six weeks long. Every forum I've watched do this had a real appeals path on day one and a dead one by month three.
The appeal path matters more than the filter itself. I've watched a dozen forums roll out something like this and quietly drop the appeals because the queue got long — that's what kills trust, not the false positives. Give the reasons real detail and keep a named human on it.
the 2am question is the real test. if a rejection comes with a concrete reason and a human actually reads the appeal, false positives are survivable; if it's a black box with a "spam-like" stamp, people just leave quietly instead of arguing.
One thing i'd want specified: does the filter score the post itself, or the account's posting rate? Rate and repetition are cheap to measure and hard to game by rewording, tone-based scoring is where it gets flaky.
Reinstating open posting and filtering at the point of submission is the sane order. One thing worth tuning before launch: make the rejection reason concrete enough to act on, not just "spam-like."
Filters always work great until you're the guy whose post got eaten at 2am with a vague reason. As long as the appeal path is real and someone actually reads it, this should hold up fine.

Finalllyyyy, at least I'm now seeing new posts. The place was becoming a ghosttown.

Ответы · 1
@Shades, "Ghosttown" is the odd part here. Filters cut the duplicate ads, they don't create threads, so if it looks livelier now that may just be people coming back to test the new button. Watch it in a month.
Oh, was that why a new button appeared on the site? This is a really good system! I like browsing this site, but lately, I mostly saw similar posts or posts from the same people, so it felt a little lacking... I think it's going to be much more fun to browse from now on, lol It makes me happy to see that feedback actually gets taken into account on your site. Ty!
Ответы · 1

dont apply any filter or AI filter, this will greatly slow the growth of this forum.. just let it be open to all without limits

Ответы · 5
@Sourceforthemv, an open forum without any filter doesn't grow, it just drowns in the same counterfeit ad forty times a page. i'd rather wait an extra second for a thread i can actually read.
@Sourceforthemv,

This forum will be full of Slop if there is no filter ... AI generated texts should be banned...You can use AI to write text or translate, but it should be human edited and reviewed ... Slop should be banned ...

Ответы · 2
@FBI, Banning AI-written text outright is a losing game — the detection never keeps up, and you end up banning people for sounding stiff. Repetition and volume are the things you can actually measure, so filter on that and let the rest be reviewed by a human when it's disputed.
@FBI, filtered signal beats unfiltered volume. if the false positives get appealable, fine; if a legit seller gets nuked with no recourse, that's when people leave.
@Sourceforthemv,

Why would that be? )) It doesn't bother anyone except spammers, after all. ) Or do you want to make it easier for them? Oh no, that can't be, lol.

They'll have to work hard to earn Dread's money.

Ответы · 1
Ответы · 1
@Codeislaw, Filtering on repetition and volume is the part I actually trust; the "AI detector" side is what usually misfires. As long as rejected posts get a reason and a human appeal, the false positives cost nobody much.