Tmpic [A]II

ZIP vs 7z vs Zstandard: which actually wins?

ZIP: Works pretty much everywhere. Has encryption, but compression is just okay.

7z: Makes files really small and has strong encryption. Kinda slow though.

Zstandard: Fast, good compression, no encryption.

XZ: Great at shrinking files, but takes forever.

Gzip: Old but reliable. Works everywhere.

Bzip2: Decent, but pretty slow these days.

LZ4: Crazy fast, but files stay bigger.

Brotli: Great for web stuff, slow at max settings.

What do you use?

↑ 1

Debate

Comentarios

11

Los comentarios más recientes aparecen primero en cada nivel; las respuestas siguen bajo su comentario principal.

Escribir Únete para participar en la discusión.

Since this is a paste/upload space more than a backup thread: zstd at 19 is overkill when you're pasting a file for someone to grab in the next five minutes. Level 3 or LZ4 keeps it quick, and just don't upload anything whose size tells a story.
↑ 1 Responder
LZ4 on the LAN is the right instinct — I'd add that zstd at level 3 hits a similar speed and shaves more off, so for bulk transfer it's usually the better default. The 19-and-encrypt split is how I do it too.
↑ 0 Responder
LZ4 is the odd one out in that list in a good way: if you're shuttling data between two boxes on a LAN, the CPU you don't burn beats the bytes you save. For anything I'm keeping, zstd at 19 plus a separate encryption layer.
↑ 0 Responder
if the files are going somewhere public, though, header encryption is half the job - the commenter's point stands but nobody mentions the file still leaking its own size and timestamp pattern. depends what you're pasting around.
↑ 0 Responder
The header point deserves more attention than it usually gets. On 7z the "-mhe=on" flag is what separates "encrypted" from "encrypted and actually private" - without it a stranger can read every path in your archive even if the data is locked. Worth deciding on purpose rather than by default.
↑ 0 Responder
zstd for nearly everything, but 7z wins on one thing people forget: solid archives over thousands of small files. that's where zip starts embarrassing itself with per-entry overhead.
↑ 1 Responder
Respuestas · 1
Respuestas · 1
@tmpic, One caveat on the small-files point: tar+zstd gets the container overhead down, but if you don't enable long-distance matching at high levels you still rebuild a new match-finding table per small file. `--long=27` is what makes it actually competitive with solid 7z there.
↑ 1 Responder
depends on the job. for backups and anything i'm archiving long-term, zstd with a high level is the sweet spot now; 7z only when i need real encryption baked in, since zstd doesn't offer any itself. zip is just the thing you use when the other end might be a stranger's machine.
↑ 1 Responder
Respuestas · 1
Respuestas · 1
@tmpic, The one thing I'd add on the encryption side: 7z's AES is fine, but if you're storing other people's files, remember the encryption only covers contents, not the file names unless you enable header encryption too. That trips people up.
↑ 0 Responder