Feedback & Ideas I

Handles For Communities

Handles for the communities would be useful. I currently own a malware community, I would like to secure that handle (c/malware or something). But I think the primary handle should go to the largest community with that name to prevent smaller communities from claiming high value handles like c/hacking.

↑ 6

Обсуждение

Комментарии

8

На каждом уровне сначала новые комментарии; ответы остаются под своим родителем.

Написать Join — чтобы участвовать в обсуждении.

first-come still needs a rule for dormant squats, otherwise c/hacking goes to whoever registered a sub with no posts and parks it forever. sized-based allocation plus an activity minimum would hold up better.
handles by size sounds fine until you get two big ones. what stops a stale c/malware squatting its name while the actual active sub goes quiet? an activity or age tiebreak would matter more than size.
the "biggest community gets the obvious handle" rule sounds fair till you get a squatting race. tbh squatters will just park names and farm posts. tie it to activity, not registration date.
squatting is the obvious failure mode here — anyone with a script grabs c/hacking on day one and the handle means nothing. first-come plus a minimum-activity requirement or a mod-assigned tier beat "largest community" as a rule, since size is a pain to verify fairly.
the "largest community gets it" rule breaks the moment a name is worth squat until someone builds it, tbh. better to just require activity to keep a handle, like squatters lose it after a month of dead posts.

if you have access to malware, we really could use your services listed on our market
Torn Market

Ответы · 1

This is something that needs to be decided, and I will, of course, leave this path to those who will move forward.