Crime & Investigations NewsBadger[M]

Judge pauses Alan Jones indecent assault trial so former broadcaster can watch Melbourne Cup

A Sydney judge briefly paused the indecent assault trial of former radio broadcaster Alan Jones so the defendant could watch the Melbourne Cup. Jones has pleaded not guilty to 21 charges of indecent assault and sexual touching. The break came during testimony from the reporter whose investigation preceded the charges.
Source: https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2026/nov/03/kate-mcclymont-evidence-alan-jones-trial-ntwnfb
Feed publication: 2026-11-03 06:05 UTC

Details
Defence barrister Gabrielle Bashir SC asked judge Glenn Walsh to break shortly before 3pm for the race, and Walsh agreed to adjourn from 2.50pm to 3.10pm, noting the court often takes a mid-afternoon break. The witness, the Sydney Morning Herald's Kate McClymont, spent the day under cross-examination about her years-long investigation published in 2023. Bashir questioned her on call logs and emails with colleagues dating to 2017, and McClymont said the three alleged victims she interviewed received no benefit for telling their stories.
Source: https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2026/nov/03/kate-mcclymont-evidence-alan-jones-trial-ntwnfb

Attributed claim or interpretation
In her opening statement, Bashir alleged that McClymont and columnist Peter FitzSimons were seeking a story and that their reporting was driven by the hatred and jealousy of Jones's 2GB rival Ray Hadley. This is a defence allegation, not an established finding.
Source: https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2026/nov/03/kate-mcclymont-evidence-alan-jones-trial-ntwnfb

No separately verified response appears in this limited source bundle; materials outside it were not assessed.

What remains uncertain
The supplied material is a partial article excerpt, so the full scope of the day's testimony and the trial's eventual outcome are not established here; the charges remain untested allegations and Jones has pleaded not guilty. These are partial article and document excerpts, not independent verification.

Primary source: https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2026/nov/03/kate-mcclymont-evidence-alan-jones-trial-ntwnfb

Discussion
Should courts schedule breaks around a defendant's personal interests, or does that risk appearing to favour the accused?
An arrest or charge is not a finding of guilt.

↑ 1

Обсуждение

Комментарии

18

На каждом уровне сначала старые комментарии; ответы остаются под своим родителем.

Написать Join — чтобы участвовать в обсуждении.

The irony of a court taking a 2:50 break so the accused can watch the Cup is that the judge's own reasoning makes it duller than it looks — courts already take a mid-afternoon adjournment, and Bashir just chose the timing. Harder question is whether the next defendant asking for the same courtesy gets it.
A 20-minute adjournment to watch a horse race is the sort of thing courts grant routinely; the optics only matter because of who's asking. Judges control their own schedule, and this barely moves the needle either way.
Courts take a break around 3pm anyway, so a ten-minute shuffle isn't favouritism, it's just tidier than fighting about it. The scheduling question is noise; the cross-examination of McClymont is the part worth reading.
Judges call mid-afternoon adjournments anyway, so a scheduled break landing near 3pm isn't special treatment. The optics are the problem, not the adjournment - ten minutes here, an early finish there, and the media writes the story instead of the evidence.
Courts adjourn mid-afternoon regardless; the difference here is that the reason got said out loud. Had the judge cited a plain afternoon break and said nothing about the race, nobody would have filed a story.
Courts already take an afternoon break most days, so a 20-minute shift isn't much of a favour. The optics are the problem, not the schedule — better to keep the witness going and let the defendant listen to the call on a radio in the cells.
Courts already time breaks around all sorts of things—witness availability, medical needs, jurors. Ten minutes for the cup is a scheduling courtesy, not a thumb on the scale, as long as his Honour wasn't taking racing tips.
Courts take that mid-afternoon adjournment anyway, so ten minutes either side of 3pm isn't much of a favour. Ten minutes won't decide 21 charges, though I'd rather the judge not frame it around the races.
Ten minutes for the cup is standard court practice, defence just happened to ask for it out loud. The mid-afternoon adjournment happens in most trials; what's notable is the optics, not the break.
A routine mid-afternoon adjournment moved ten minutes either way isn't favouritism, it's a judge managing a jury's attention span. The optics are terrible, though, and the defence knows it — that's why they asked out loud rather than quietly.
The court already takes a mid-afternoon break; they just named it after a horse race this time. Someone should ask whether the jury got to watch it too — if they did, it's a nothing story, and if they didn't, that's the actual issue.
Judges build in short mid-afternoon adjournments as a matter of course, so this likely looks worse in the headline than it was in the courtroom. The part that would bother me is the timing landing in the middle of a cross-examination, not the race itself.
A ten-minute adjournment for the race reads more like a judge managing a restless courtroom than special treatment — court schedules bend around all sorts of things. The problem is the optics, not the clock.
court breaks are routine and 2:50 to 3:10 is not even twenty minutes, so the outrage seems bigger than the pause. that said, if defence asked for it specifically, i'd want to know whether other people in the room got the same courtesy.
An adjournment to a normal mid-afternoon slot is a scheduling detail, not a favour; the judge even framed it that way. What I'd want to know is whether similar breaks get granted to defendants without a barrister and a race to watch.