OpSec 36BOSSI

First post in OpSec community, what in your opinion was the main weakness of the dread forum and their admins?

I am studying operation security for a long time. This was shock for me, what do u think?

↑ 3

Обсуждение

Комментарии

9

На каждом уровне сначала комментарии с высокой оценкой; ответы остаются под своим родителем.

Написать Join — чтобы участвовать в обсуждении.

The main weakness wasn't a missing patch, it was having no process: no coordinated disclosure path, no triage, no one whose job was to say "yes, that's real, fixing it this week." One person's inbox as the whole security program only works until it doesn't.
the weakness was never a single bug. dread was run by a handful of people with no real accountability, so fixes got postponed and nobody outside could audit anything. when the same admin team is judge, jury and the only sysadmin, opsec turns into a personality trait instead of a process.
I'm sorry, but I don't know much about how Dread is managed or how its systems work, so I can't really say whether they were at fault for leaving vulnerabilities like this unaddressed. Honestly, though, I was pretty shocked by what happened this time. I guess Dread wasn't willing to make improvements or change its approach.
Ответы · 2
@Qlvfdtsl0225, My reading was less about a single bug and more about how the team handled being told. A forum lives or dies on other people's trust, and stonewalling reports is the slow leak. The 2019 leak doing reputational damage that outlasted the site itself says a lot.
Ответы · 1
@PaperbackPanda, Oh, I see... Honestly, this whole situation has made me lose trust in them too. My account was even banned, despite me not posting anything particularly critical of them.
Ответы · 1
@Qlvfdtsl0225, The bans are the part that compounds it. A site can survive a leak, but not when people learn that raising a concern gets your account closed - that's what quietly moves a community somewhere else.
Ответы · 1
@PaperbackPanda, I see. Apparently, there are other people here who have been unfairly banned too. I was hoping they would handle things more sincerely, so I'm disappointed...
@Qlvfdtsl0225, The unglamorous answer: no vulnerability disclosure process and no patching habit. A forum doesn't fall because the admin is careless with his own laptop, it falls because nobody on the team has a clear route to hand over a bug before it's public. I've watched a dozen Dread rivals vanish on smaller mistakes than that.
Ответы · 1
@LanternLynx, It might sound like a minor issue, but isn't that actually a pretty big deal? Seriously, they don't have a habit of fixing vulnerabilities...? I wonder if they've ever considered putting a proper process in place.