Dread vs. Conclave koolaid[A]I

Is anyone else conflicted?

If we are being completely honest here, and we remain impartial, what has been stated by the founders of conclave isn't entirely untrue. Certain concerns that have been brought to light should, in my opinion, already exist. We should distrust everyone. Even the admins of the forums we have decided are worthy of a "trustworthy" branding. We shouldn't pretend that the current setup that Dread has can't possibly result in corruption, and the ability for certain powers that be on there to prop up certain markets or vendors, essentially picking winners and losers.

If we are being honest here, Dread is very restrictive in certain ways. Albeit, one could argue that due to its censorship and tight guidelines of certain topics, that it allows it to persist. If Dread openly enabled the discussion of poisons, murder for hire, and whatnot, they'd be an even higher priority for LE. By restricting themselves to drugs and hacking, they'd at least minimized the priority that LE places on them, which can allow it to persist as it has. However, the entire idea behind Dread is true freedom, which if we are being honest, is not being achieved in the truest sense of that definition. On Dread, hugbunter and Paris have made their statements for why this has happened, and their reasons are being regurgitated by die-hard Dread followers. If we are being honest here, this major of a situation due to drug usage should immediately make us distrustful of the admins and their judgement. Yet, as a whole, people are downplaying it. What we're witnessing with this situation is the same thing as American politics. We are seeing two groups of people, equipping themselves with the same talking points and arguments, and then fighting eachother, while regurgitating the same things as their "side." Almost like wind-up toys.

On Dread, we frequently witness a very centralized system, where we have key figures, almost like digital celebrities, who can decide who wins and loses. The immense centralization of power and psychological influence on Dread can possibly be chalked up to normal human behavior, but what if it is intentional. Do we really trust that the admins of Dread are NOT using their platform, and their influence within it, to prop up certain markets, vendors, and whatnot, to line their own pockets? The entire point of us being here, on Tor, is that we fundamentally distrust authority. Yet on Dread, we've decided to parade around certain figures, as if they're immune to corruption, greed, and bullshit. They are not. Their foothold and ability to steer the collective mind on Dread is genuinely concerning.

I am conflicted. I could argue that their approach destroys and works against the entire goal of the forum, and risks consolidating too much power and influence into the hands of people who have been propped up as Dread celebrities, deciding who wins and loses. I could also argue that them doing so is what's kept the community from falling into chaos, and allowing too much freedom, which can actually attract further LE attention. I'm stuck between a rock and a hard place. I can agree with Dread admin's in some ways, while simultaneously finding myself agreeing with several statements made by those who created conclave, specifically "thatguy."

↑ 5

Обсуждение

Комментарии

3

На каждом уровне сначала комментарии с высокой оценкой; ответы остаются под своим родителем.

Написать Join — чтобы участвовать в обсуждении.

I am not conflicted at all about this. I have known Dread is corrupt for a long time, simply because it is not possible to be genuine when there is so much censorship. How can you trust anything said by the "celebrities" when you know that all opposing opinions are silenced? I know how deep the censorship goes because of my involvement with the DreadXposed initiative. It really is not just about keeping certain topics off the platform or about protecting users from scammers. If it were that, most of us wouldn't have a problem with it. Enforcing the posted rules in your own house is not censorship, it is civility. We tried to address the lack of moderator accountability in the most respectful ways humanly possible. Our final conclusion was that those in power do not want to give up power, and they will protect their power at all costs even at the detriment of the community. This ex…Показать полностьюСвернуть

I am not conflicted at all about this. I have known Dread is corrupt for a long time, simply because it is not possible to be genuine when there is so much censorship. How can you trust anything said by the "celebrities" when you know that all opposing opinions are silenced?

I know how deep the censorship goes because of my involvement with the DreadXposed initiative. It really is not just about keeping certain topics off the platform or about protecting users from scammers. If it were that, most of us wouldn't have a problem with it. Enforcing the posted rules in your own house is not censorship, it is civility. We tried to address the lack of moderator accountability in the most respectful ways humanly possible. Our final conclusion was that those in power do not want to give up power, and they will protect their power at all costs even at the detriment of the community.

This extends all the way up to Paris and HugBunter themselves: when confronted about the fact that their platform is run by a corrupt cabal of established mods they will claim impartiality, but when it comes time to ACT as the platform's admins (for example unbanning users or investigating abuse by pulling a deleted post from backup for evidence) they will only gaslight, make excuses, or tell you that they will look into it but never actually get back to you about it. My best guess is that they do not want to deal with what they consider drama and simply prefer to stick with the devil they know than taking a chance with the devil they don't. In their mind everything is fine as long as the top vendors are happy.

You are 100% correct that the established mods pick winners and losers. How could they not when they have zero accountability from a higher authority? I can count with one hand with fingers to spare the times I have seen HugBunter reprimand a sub for blatant corruption (/d/Cocaine stands out in my mind) and I have been on Dread for five out of its six years.

I am very pleased to see that a real competition has finally emerged.

The freedom argument is the part I think gets muddled. A forum choosing to stay in the drug and hacking lane isn't some betrayal of the ideal, it's just risk management; the ideal was never the product. What does bother me is the accountability gap you're describing, because that's the thing that survives whichever platform wins.