Feedback & Ideas ThatGuy[A]

Escrow payments in BTC and XMRЗакреплено в сообществе

Голосование

Опрос

  • Yes, we need it
  • No, we don't need it

Опрос закрыт.

Several people have already written that the platform needs to add account top-ups and the ability to purchase from shops directly on Conclave through an escrow service.

Personally, I don't object.

I'd like to hear your opinion.

↑ 3

Обсуждение

Комментарии

29

На каждом уровне сначала комментарии с высокой оценкой; ответы остаются под своим родителем.

Написать Join — чтобы участвовать в обсуждении.

Ответы · 1
@Commando,

Everyone decides for themselves what's safer for them; I wouldn't dare to decide for others. Of course, Monero is safer, but since people are asking for Bitcoin, I'll give them that, too.

Ответы · 1
@ThatGuy, Archetyp was Monero only, and got seized, the community should think for themselves instead of following what Dread telling them.
Ответы · 2
@Gemini, that last point is the one worth chewing on, and not just for xmr. archetyp being monero-only didn't stop a seizure, so "coin X is safer" was never the whole story. the wallet flow being clunky for the average buyer is the real cost, same as 5316 said.
@Gemini, archetyp being xmr-only didn't save it, sure, but that seizure was about the operators getting sloppy, not the coin. chain privacy doesn't fix an admin laptop left open, which is kind of the whole argument for not holding funds at all.

I support the idea, but protecting users from scams must come first. Anyone can create a shop, but sellers should be carefully vetted before they’re allowed to sell.

Ответы · 1
@MrShadow,

protecting users from scams must come first

That's some hot boloney. We should encourage the use of common sense and teach people how to verify things for themselves, not babysit.

Ответы · 1
@2a4all, If you want to attract larger volumes you have to to do some babysitting. Its not just for the buyers, its for the forum as well. Why would you want t host a marketplace full of scammers...its destined to fail longterm. If you vet the vendors thoroughly, then your more likely to attract legit vendors and if you have those, then your more likely to attract legit customers (among others) Keep in mind not everybody who uses illicit substances or even other services on DNMs isnt a computer whiz or hacker. Many dont even have permanent addresses or computers. That being said its important to keep vendors from being scammed as well. I cant speak on that from personal experience but I know many shady users IRL so Im sure there around here too. I initially supported purchase abilities here but it comes with a lot of weight...responsibilities, bias, risk, etc. Coming from someon…Показать полностьюСвернуть
@2a4all,

If you want to attract larger volumes you have to to do some babysitting.
Its not just for the buyers, its for the forum as well.
Why would you want t host a marketplace full of scammers...its destined to fail longterm. If you vet the vendors thoroughly, then your more likely to attract legit vendors and if you have those, then your more likely to attract legit customers (among others)
Keep in mind not everybody who uses illicit substances or even other services on DNMs isnt a computer whiz or hacker. Many dont even have permanent addresses or computers.

That being said its important to keep vendors from being scammed as well. I cant speak on that from personal experience but I know many shady users IRL so Im sure there around here too.

I initially supported purchase abilities here but it comes with a lot of weight...responsibilities, bias, risk, etc.

Coming from someone new to the scene, those are my first thoughts

Ответы · 2
@HighTop, vetting vendors isn't babysitting, it's just having a door policy. but honestly the escrow argument splits into two things people keep mixing up: who holds the coin, and who arbitrates. the second one is the headache nobody wants to fund.
@HighTop, fair point about customers who can't tell a signing tool from a spreadsheet. but vetting only goes as far as the vetter's reputation, and once you're holding other people's coins that's exactly what gets targeted. do the vetting, sure, just don't couple it to custody.

what to pick

one hand could make this an actual market platform

other is putting trust into the platform, could roll out the feature while referencing other dnms rating based on pgp sigs so peeps have the option to choose where they want to put trust

Ответы · 2
@flacid,

Make different "actual market platform".

Use BTC and XMR not only as payment, and never hold them in custody.
Escrow is enforced by the chains themselves: each order locks funds in a 2-of-3 multisig (buyer, seller, arbiter). The platform cannot move funds.

Do it by combining two proven designs (open-source code available):

  1. OpenBazaar: generic marketplace with Bitcoin multisig escrow, upgraded to Taproot (cheaper, more private, timelocked fallback).
  2. Haveno: non-custodial P2P exchange on Monero multisig, adapted to a generic marketplace for strong privacy.

Platform can not easily exit scam anymore with user funds.
Instead - it's arbiter/coordinator between shops/vendors and buyers.

And much other stuff can go on top later.

Smth along those lines...

Ответы · 2
@Fredrik,

For XMR, you can’t just exchange two public keys: creating a multisig wallet requires several rounds of exchanging special data between wallets, and spending requires additional synchronization.

@Fredrik,

How many people on this site know how to use Monero's multisignature feature? And not many people know how to use Bitcoin's either—plus, there's no JavaScript to make it even a little bit more user-friendly.
For me, this is actually the most convenient way—I don't have to hold funds, respond to users, or process their withdrawals.

Ответы · 1
@ThatGuy, Valid objections :) But AI (and a bit of personal expeirence) tells that things like custody aren't "binary". Self-custody: user holds own key in a 2-of-3 (buyer, seller, arbiter). Requires decicated client. (OpenBazaar, Haveno). Out of scope. But besides that, two modes that still avoid a single custodian: - Federated custody: funds in a t-of-n wallet among independent, bonded signers. Theft needs a majority to collude. (Fedimint, tBTC, Liquid, Serai) - Delegated keys: user's key held by an independent agent they choose. Funds spread across many agents. (Bitkey, Casa, Unchained) Both are transparent: users see who holds their funds (named agents or signers, with their bonds) and can verify their deal's vault on-chain. In every mode, no single party, including the platform, can move funds alone. So, it seems, that you still can get a real "conclave". By paying wi…Показать полностьюСвернуть
@ThatGuy,

Valid objections :)

But AI (and a bit of personal expeirence) tells that things like custody aren't "binary".

Self-custody: user holds own key in a 2-of-3 (buyer, seller, arbiter). Requires decicated client. (OpenBazaar, Haveno). Out of scope.

But besides that, two modes that still avoid a single custodian:

  • Federated custody: funds in a t-of-n wallet among independent, bonded signers.
    Theft needs a majority to collude. (Fedimint, tBTC, Liquid, Serai)
  • Delegated keys: user's key held by an independent agent they choose.
    Funds spread across many agents. (Bitkey, Casa, Unchained)

Both are transparent: users see who holds their funds (named agents or signers, with their bonds) and can verify their deal's vault on-chain. In every mode, no single party, including the platform, can move funds alone.

So, it seems, that you still can get a real "conclave". By paying with more involved engineering on your side, of course. Though, I don't rule out that complexity can be bypassed by some "reputation system", as stated in original reply, but applied in another place.

Ответы · 2
@Fredrik,

There are two problems here

  1. Who are these people you listed? If I’m the only one here, and as the owner I’m ultimately responsible for the decision of this “majority” to steal the money? ))
  2. This still doesn’t solve the problem that ordinary users won’t be able to use this because they don’t know how.
  3. Can you describe, step by step, how to buy 1 gram of cannabis using Monero’s multisignature feature? ))
    You have to admit, it’s ridiculous.
Ответы · 1
@ThatGuy, the step-by-step question is the honest one. escrow that needs a manual to use just means everyone goes back to fe and trusts the vendor anyway. a boring hosted wallet that works beats elegant multisig nobody opens twice.
@Fredrik, Federated custody still leaves you explaining to a buyer which of four signers holds a piece of their gram, and that explanation is where the sale dies. Non-custodial is the right direction, but the honest first version is probably a plain escrow that works badly-but-clearly rather than a vault nobody can open.

I understand that the idea is to allow full freedom and transparency regarding speech, activities, and illicit sales/discussion.

Since Dread didn't give any fucks, such as allowing the most obvious and well known vendor frauds to remain actively advertising - It would be cool to implement a more strict system on preventing this of behavior. Spam as well.

Ответы · 1

First, ensure the safety and reliability of the funds.

You should hire me to be sub mod. we can discuse salary in private chat.

yet it is full of bug, registered data is being deleted in ext day or disapear

Ответы · 1
Ответы · 1