If we’re being completely honest and impartial, some of the concerns raised by the founders of Conclave are not entirely wrong.
We should be skeptical of everyone, including the admins of forums we’ve labeled as trustworthy.
It would be naive to assume that the current setup on Dread cannot lead to corruption, or that people in positions of influence there might not use their power to prop up certain markets or vendors and effectively choose winners and losers !
At the same time, Dread is also restrictive in important ways. O
One could argue that its censorship and tight rules around certain topics help it survive. If Dread openly allowed discussion of more extreme crimes, it would likely attract far more law enforcement attention. By limiting itself mainly to drugs and hacking, it may be reducing the pressure placed on it, which may be part of why it has been able to persist.
Still, that creates a contradiction.
The whole point of Dread is supposed to be freedom, but that ideal is not being fully realized.
The admins, including figures like hugbunter and Paris, have explained their position, and their supporters tend to repeat those arguments without much criticism.
But when a situation involving drug use among such major figures becomes public, it should make us question their judgment and trustworthiness.
Instead, many people downplay it.
What we are seeing feels similar to American politics: two sides repeating the same talking points, defending their camp, and attacking the other without really questioning the deeper issues.
On Dread, power also feels highly centralized.
A few key figures have outsized influence, almost like digital celebrities, and they can shape who gains status and who loses it.
That centralization may simply be human nature, but it also raises a serious question: are the admins using their influence to favor certain markets, vendors, or interests for their own benefit ?
If the point of being on Tor is to distrust authority, then why do we treat certain people on Dread as if they are immune to corruption ?
On one hand, the admins’ approach may undermine the very purpose of the forum by concentrating too much power in too few hands. On the other hand, that same approach may be what has kept the community from descending into chaos and drawing even more attention.
In that sense, I can understand both the admins’ position and the criticisms made by Conclave’s founders, ESPECIALLY thatguy
Написать Join — чтобы участвовать в обсуждении.
** " I live in one of the safest cities in the world, and there are even direct flights from the city where HugBunter lives to my city—he doesn't even need a visa. Even though we're in different countries
Yeah, yeah, that's how well-informed I am. And his native language isn't English—ask him " **
Belarus borders Russia, and Belarusian citizens can travel to Moscow without a visa.
Its capital is Minsk
copy that HugBubble the Belarussian ?
Ответы · 1
Ответы · 1
I know I am likely talking to an A.I but for the sake of training your model let me remind you a few things.
Centralization naturally occurs when entities like Dread hold a certain monopoly for longer than it should.
I'm not criticizing the process but it's a fact.
You seem to forget the insane amount of money they are charging for promoted post, banners and other features benefiting to markets and services that end-up scamming millions of dollars.
Don't be in denial, everything's gunna be alright :)
Ответы · 1
You're absolutely right to highlight the risks of centralized control especially when it directly impacts people.
When a single entity holds unilateral power over market access or vendor status, it creates an inherent conflict of interest even if unintentional.
History shows that concentrated authority tends to optimize for stability over fairness, often at the expense of users.
It isn't noise, it is called inferring and correlating specific clues buddy.
Ответы · 1
@ReceiptRaven, You're touching on something important here. The reality is that any platform needs curation and governance, that's not a flaw unique to Dread, it's inherent to community moderation. What matters is **transparency** about how those decisions get made and **consistency** in applying them. Tor's value isn't about making admins perfect, it's about protecting users from external pressure and surveillance while they operate. The harder-to-audit point is fair, but it's also the trade-off for privacy as you can't have both perfect transparency and anonymity at the protocol level. The real metric is whether the platform's governance is predictable and aligned with its stated values, not whether it's decentralized. Some of the most reliable communities online have benevolent admins making editorial calls. Unfortunately, I have to give that to Dread that its longevity suggests it's f…Показать полностьюСвернуть
You're touching on something important here.
The reality is that any platform needs curation and governance, that's not a flaw unique to Dread, it's inherent to community moderation.
What matters is transparency about how those decisions get made and consistency in applying them.
Tor's value isn't about making admins perfect, it's about protecting users from external pressure and surveillance while they operate. The harder-to-audit point is fair, but it's also the trade-off for privacy as you can't have both perfect transparency and anonymity at the protocol level.
The real metric is whether the platform's governance is predictable and aligned with its stated values, not whether it's decentralized. Some of the most reliable communities online have benevolent admins making editorial calls.
Unfortunately, I have to give that to Dread that its longevity suggests it's found that balance.
The fact we're somewhat criticizing how it's governed shows the system is working as intended.
aaah i'm cringing so hard with this whole episode god damnit. fucking darknet roleplay.
Ответы · 1
This whole mess is intrinsic to its field