Politics & Civil Liberties ThatGuy[A]

Orwell, Sun Tzu, and Machiavelli on War and Power

We live in a time when the only logical explanation for what is happening can be found in the writings of Orwell, Sun Tzu, and Machiavelli.

The following passages are modern paraphrases and adaptations, not verbatim quotations. Orwell’s passage draws on the fictional political treatise in Nineteen Eighty-Four; the first Machiavelli sentence is an interpretation, not his literal wording.

Orwell — modern paraphrase inspired by Nineteen Eighty-Four, Part II, Chapter IX:

This war is a fraud, for it is meant to continue indefinitely, without victory. Its main purpose is to preserve the existing order by destroying not only human lives but also the fruits of human labour, because a general rise in prosperity threatens hierarchical society with collapse. If the vast majority of people become educated and learn to think for themselves, they will dispense with the privileged minority as unnecessary. War and hunger, meanwhile, help keep people dulled by poverty in a world of illusions.

Sun Tzu — paraphrase of The Art of War, Chapter II:

When war is waged and victory is delayed, weapons grow dull and their edges break; when a fortress is besieged for too long, strength is exhausted; when an army remains in the field for too long, the state’s resources run short. Once your weapons have grown dull and their edges have broken, your strength is exhausted and your resources depleted, neighbouring powers will take advantage of your weakness and rise against you. Even if you have wise advisers, there will be nothing they can do then… There has never been a prolonged war that benefited the state.

Machiavelli — modern interpretation combining ideas from The Prince, Chapters IX and XX:

If you have gained power through an elite that stands against the people, sacrifice the elite and side with the people, for the elite can be replaced, but the people cannot… The best fortress of all is not to be hated by the people: whatever fortresses you build, they will not save you if the people hate you, for when the people take up arms, foreigners will always come to their aid.

Original texts:
Orwell — Nineteen Eighty-Four, Part II, Chapter IX: https://www.orwell.ru/library/novels/1984/english/en_p_2
Sun Tzu — The Art of War, Chapter II: https://www.gutenberg.org/files/132/132-h/132-h.htm
Machiavelli — The Prince, Chapters IX and XX: https://www.gutenberg.org/files/1232/1232-h/1232-h.htm

↑ 3

Обсуждение

Комментарии

5

На каждом уровне сначала комментарии с высокой оценкой; ответы остаются под своим родителем.

Написать Join — чтобы участвовать в обсуждении.

All very wonderful insights but i love that of Orwell most. We're very much aware at this point that the war he talks about(is both literal and metaphorical) orbits ENERGY. When you zoom in enough you'll see that in all our transactions, we either directly purchase a form of energy or another(think of energy in all forms as the same individual in different outfits), or something that 90% of what it takes to make it available and desirable is energy. At the fundamental level all they've ever sort to control for centuries is energy, when energy independence is achieved control will no longer be feasible and the status quo would collapse. The realization downed on me during a research some few years ago, that energy isn't supposed to be bought, it is simply to be harnessed, converted, maybe exchanged and consumed (independently) , all that exists living and non-living, simply coops…Показать полностьюСвернуть

All very wonderful insights but i love that of Orwell most. We're very much aware at this point that the war he talks about(is both literal and metaphorical) orbits ENERGY. When you zoom in enough you'll see that in all our transactions, we either directly purchase a form of energy or another(think of energy in all forms as the same individual in different outfits), or something that 90% of what it takes to make it available and desirable is energy.

At the fundamental level all they've ever sort to control for centuries is energy, when energy independence is achieved control will no longer be feasible and the status quo would collapse.

The realization downed on me during a research some few years ago, that energy isn't supposed to be bought, it is simply to be harnessed, converted, maybe exchanged and consumed (independently) , all that exists living and non-living, simply coops from its environment all the energy it needs - from tiny to colossal amounts - to sustain all it's processes(individually) when a means is eventually crafted during the course of it's evolution, why does the case of the human specie have to be different? Let me remind all of us that every attempt ever made in the past, to join the harmony of existence in this respect was abruptly suppressed. I happen to spot a recurring flaw in these attempts and then identified the culprit to be something tameable

sun tzu's "win without fighting" line fits this whole ad-spyware era weirdly well. tbh i keep waiting for someone to turn machiavelli into a darknet vendor playbook, that'd actually sell
Three dead guys explaining the present is a tempting shortcut, but i'm not sure any of them had a model for information being this cheap and this loud at once. Sun Tzu still holds up though, mostly because he never wasted a word.
Ответы · 1